Nature and EnvironmentNorth America
To play this audio please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
Nature and EnvironmentNorth Americahttps://p.dw.com/p/5PdfP
Send a voice message to LivingPlanet
Subscribe to the podcast here via your favorite podcast app: Living Planet Podlink
TRANSCRIPT
Karen Oberhauser: The only thing I can compare it to is if people have ever snorkeled or scuba dived, and if you’re near a coral reef and are just surrounded by fish flying or swimming around you.
That’s the only experience I’ve ever had like that… that sort of compares to the butterflies on all dimensions moving around you.
We’re in a dense fir forest, high up in the rugged mountains of central Mexico.
It’s Karen Oberhauser’s first time here. She’s not used to hiking at 11-thousand feet.
Karen: I’m from the flatlands of the Midwestern United States… So the elevation was hard for me, so I was huffing and puffing as I was walking up this mountain.
We started seeing a few butterflies flying around. And, you know, that just was so exciting to us to see them. And then we walked farther…
… deeper into the forest. To the place they’ve come to see.
It takes a minute for Karen to realize what she’s looking at. And then it dawns on her.
Karen: Just gradually I became conscious of the fact that I was looking at millions of butterflies.
… the trees were all just coated with monarchs.
Millions and millions of monarch butterflies. Lined up around the trunks of trees, in dense clumps – on logs, on branches. So tightly packed, that the branches are even sagging under their weight.
At this point, Karen has spent the better part of decade studying monarch butterflies in their breeding grounds in the US. But she’s never seen anything like this.
Karen: I just felt like I knew them so well and I just burst into tears. You know, it was so emotional… So that first sight was just incredible in so many ways.
Year after year, this is where monarch butterflies from southern Canada and the northeastern US come to shelter for the winter. Many of them have flown nearly 3,000 miles to get here.
This is a protected biosphere reserve in Mexico and it’s an incredibly special place – the only place that monarch butterflies gather in their millions.
Karen: you’re hearing their wings flapping, so you can’t hear one butterfly’s wings flapping, but you can hear millions of them… you’re hearing their wings flapping and…It’s an incredible, soft kind of, you know, gentle sound, maybe like water, or like really quiet wind chimes… I can’t compare it to anything else… I mean, there’s nothing it really sounds like… it sounds like a million butterfly wings… You hear them and you actually smell them
So it’s, it’s all of your senses are involved. But that feeling of standing in the forest with all of the butterflies flying around me, that still is something that I can recapture in my head if I shut my eyes… it is really an incredible experience.
Fast forward 30 years. Today Karen is a professor emerita at the University of Wisconsin in the Department of Entomology. Since that first visit to the butterflies’ winter home, she’s been back to Mexico again and again.
Karen: I don’t know, 20 or 25 times.
And over the years, she’s seen a change.
Karen: It’s still very amazing. But we used to be able to walk and walk and walk and walk and still see trees covered with monarchs, and that’s just not the case anymore.
She says the number of monarchs in these overwintering colonies has dropped by about 75% since the 90s. Some estimates say it’s more than 80%.
Karen: So yeah, it’s a big change… And I have to be really careful when I’m there with people who are seeing it for the first time. I have to be careful not to say, oh, this is nothing compared to what it used to be.
So what’s going on? Why are the butterflies disappearing?
The monarchs’ epic journey to get to their winter home is famous. It’s one of nature’s most spectacular feats.
But much of this long-distance migration is a mystery. There’s a lot scientists still don’t know about how the butterflies pull it off, or what threats they face along the way.
As this episode drops, millions of monarchs are streaming into Mexico as part of this year’s migration.
Some of them are carrying tiny transmitters – about as heavy as a grain of rice. Trackers that allow researchers to follow the movements of individual butterflies up close.
The hope is they’ll collect crucial intel that can be used to protect the monarchs and bring their numbers back up.
I’m Neil King and this is Living Planet.
The monarch butterfly with its striking orange and black markings is one of the most recognizable – and beloved – insects in North America.
Karen: It’s something that people see in the environment and it just kind of makes them feel like all is right with the world when they see a monarch butterfly.
Children learn about the monarch life cycle in schools.
Communities take monarch pledges to plant flowers and create butterfly habitat.
Cities also hold monarch festivals each year to celebrate its migration.
Each year, thousands of butterfly enthusiasts across North America take part in citizen science initiatives to collect data on the monarch population – from counting eggs and caterpillars to recording butterfly observations. One initiative is run by Karen – the Monarch Larva Monitoring Project – which she started in 1997.
This is all to say that the monarch is one of the most well-studied butterflies out there. And yet, serious gaps remain when it comes to what we know about its migration.
Karen: And that’s a significant part of their lives. It’s a really important transition for them.
Researchers have been trying to understand this incredible journey for decades.
Greg: People have been experimenting with sticker tagging, putting little, little ID tags with, with a location on them on the wing since 1937. And that’s that program actually started at the University of Toronto in Canada.
That’s Greg Mitchell. He’s a research scientist with the Canadian government based in the capital, Ottawa.
Back in the 1930s, it was a Canadian zoologist named Fred Urquhart who began tagging monarch butterflies to try to figure out where they were flying to. He glued paper tags to their wings, with a message telling anyone who recaptured the insects further south to send them back to the University of Toronto.
It wasn’t until 1975 that they finally discovered the monarch’s winter colonies in Mexico.
A version of this low-tech sticker-tagging campaign still takes place each year. Thousands of volunteers get involved.
But only a fraction of these tags are recovered in Mexico. And Greg says there are other limitations.
Greg: These recaptures – most of the time they are several hundred, if not 1000km apart…
…If we sticker tagged a monarch on the north shore of Lake Erie or Lake Ontario, one of the Great Lakes in Canada, and then that monarch was recaptured in Texas. Well, we know it made it from A to B, and if you draw that straight line, that’s all the information we have. We don’t know how it got there. Did it cross the Great Lakes? Did it go around the Great Lakes did it, you know, hook to the west and then move south?… And so what we’ve been lacking is what is going on in between location A and location B.
So, when his team at Environment and Climate Change Canada got the chance in 2025 to try out new radio tags that promised to fill in those gaps, they went for it.
Greg: I was talking to my research technician. I’m like, do we buy ten to try these out? Like, how good are they going to be? Do we buy 30 and just hope that they work? And so we ended up gambling and going with the 30…
This tag weighs about as much as a grain of rice. It’s powered by a tiny solar panel – so doesn’t need a battery – and transmits at the same frequency as Bluetooth. Meaning its signal, sent out from a flying butterfly, can be picked up by smartphones that are in range.
Greg: I thought, well, that sounds too good to be true…
Lee: Most people now have a smartphone. So you actually have a bunch of people walking around with little receivers in their pockets.
That’s Lee Brown. She’s an entomologist in the US – at James Madison University in Harrisonburg, Virginia. She was involved early on, conducting studies to make sure the tags wouldn’t affect the butterflies’ ability to fly.
Lee: This question of like, are they actually too heavy?
Her tests showed they weren’t.
But also: what was the best way to attach the tags? It needed to be a non-toxic glue that wouldn’t harm the butterfly, but strong enough to keep the tag fixed over thousands of miles. In the end, they settled on eyelash glue. And they developed a process:
Lee: You know, put the monarch on the pinning board, put the glassine envelopes over their wings first … and then put weights over the wings to hold them down… we noticed that they like to flick their abdomen up a lot. So then we ended up having to put something over the abdomen to hold that down. We put a little bit of eyelash glue right on the thorax and then a little bit on the underside of the tag and wait for it to dry a bit… You wait for it to get tacky, and then you put the tag on from there and then release the butterfly.
We’ll leave Lee for now, but she’s going to play an important role later on.
MUSIC – if music running underneath, it could end here to signify transition
(this bit switches to present tense)
It’s showtime. Mid-September 2025. Greg and his colleague have come out to a place called Long Point. It’s a popular birding area on the northern shore of Lake Erie – just across from the US border.
Migrating monarchs also gather here every year before they set off on their journey.
Greg’s been out catching the butterflies with big nets.
They glue the tiny tags on the insects one by one and keep them in an enclosure for a few minutes, just to make sure they’re flying ok.
Then, they release them.
And they wait.
Greg: The next morning … we loaded up the data portal and my mind was just blown to see, like almost every monarch that we had tagged the day before had flown across Lake Erie, which is only about 80km wide, I think at its widest point, but that’s still a huge water crossing. And it was getting picked up by boats that were crossing the lake. And then to see how quickly they were moving, right through the heart of these large US cities.
Over three days, they release 30 monarchs. For the first time, Greg can see the path of each individual butterfly.
Greg: … it’s really fascinating to watch. So this tagging technology is allowing us to fill in the gaps, see fine scale movement detail that we’ve never been able to see before.
If the wind conditions are good, monarchs can cover more than 100 miles a day. They mainly use thermal air currents to climb high into the air and glide – rather than wasting precious energy flapping their wings.
Day by day, Greg watches on as the butterflies make tracks across the continent, heading towards Mexico.
Greg: And I thought to myself, my gosh, they’re moving way faster than I ever thought they would move…I just thought, there’s no way they can. I mean, I thought to myself, they’re going to be in Mexico in like a few weeks at this rate. Like this is insane.
I was just amazed by the level of detail, almost shaking because it was like, you just can’t imagine having this kind of detailed data for almost any species, let alone a butterfly that weighs 0.5grams.
The tags are the world’s smallest wildlife tracking device to date – developed by a New Jersey-based company called Cellular Tracking Technologies. They also developed a free app called Project Monarch Science, where researchers – and members of the public – can follow the tagged butterflies.
Most of Greg’s monarchs are barreling along at a cracking pace. But when they reach Texas, something changes. The butterflies stall and many stop moving. There’s a clear reason for that:
Greg: the weather was just horrible, like the winds were blowing hard from the south up to the north. The monarchs just couldn’t go anywhere. They fly at about the average wind speed in North America. So kind of in the 4 to 5m/s range. That’s on average what the wind speed is here. So the winds really do dictate how quickly or not they can move.
The weather holds them up and they likely have to hunker down. Ten of the trackers go quiet – meaning the butterflies carrying them have probably died.
Greg’s not the only one keenly watching the migration – scientists across Canada and the US put out more than 400 of the trackers on migrating monarchs. Including Lee Brown, remember? The scientist who was testing the trackers at the start. Well, she also releases her own group of butterflies.
Lee: There was a playful competition of like, oh, what’s this one doing? What’s this one doing? So someone was always looking and like, oh, where’s this one going? Look at that one.
Lee tags 20 butterflies in Virginia with the ID JMU – for James Madison University. She’s following them on the Project Monarch app.
Lee: I look at the app and … like I want to see where they’re going. But then I’m also afraid to look because if they don’t move or they stop moving, I’m like, no. And I start to worry or I feel bad… Not all of them are going to make it. Whether or not they’re tagged… I think I worry more just because, you know, you want to like see them moving and then, but of course, like, again, they’re insects. Not everyone makes it.
What she soon notices is that the butterflies aren’t all taking the same route. About half are tracking west, crossing the Great Plains, then hooking south and funneling down through Texas – where you might expect them to go to get to Mexico. But some also go north. Some head in the other direction – down to Florida.
Lee: They’re doing crazy things… So it seems like, you know, there’s so much we didn’t know. And now sometimes the question is, you know what? We don’t know that we actually didn’t even realize we didn’t know. And so far, you know, in some ways, there have been more questions than answers because the technology is still really new.
In the end, of the 30 butterflies Greg tagged, three make it to down to the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve in Mexico. As for Lee, four of her monarchs reach their destination.
Lee: which was pretty amazing.
Of the 400-plus butterflies tagged across the continent, one of hers wins the race – it’s the first to reach Mexico in early November. A male butterfly with the tag JMU004.
Lee: It was sort of a proof of concept for me that these monarchs actually were able to move these long distances with tags. So that was meaningful to me. But, I’ve said before, you know, it’s not about who wins the race, but rather like we actually would just like to see as many as possible moving.
This same butterfly JMU004 survives the winter, and come spring, it’s there on the app, moving north again, toward Texas. It heads past San Antonio, and then somewhere southeast of Dallas, in March, its tracker stops pinging.
When winter’s ending, and it starts getting warmer, monarch butterflies in Mexico start moving back into the US – like Lee’s butterfly did. That’s around February-March.
They mate, lay eggs, then die. The eggs hatch, the next generation develops and continues the journey north, before breeding, laying eggs and dying. You get the idea.
The cycle repeats as the butterflies gradually move back to their breeding grounds in the northern part of the continent.
Each monarch typically lives two to six weeks. But in late summer, there’s a shift. The monarchs born around this time are what’s called a “super generation.” These ones live up to nine months, so they can fly down to Mexico to escape the winter cold. Rather than mating and laying eggs like their parents and grandparents did, their reproductive systems go into pause mode. They channel that energy into their migration instead.
And they need all the energy they can get! They’ve got a lot of ground to cover.
Karen: Every time I talk about it, I kind of get goose bumps on the back of my neck.
That’s Karen Oberhauser, who we heard from at the start of the episode.
Monarchs power their long flight by feeding on nectar along the way, building up their fat stores.
They navigate using a sun compass, that keeps them headed in the right direction – pairing the angle of the sun with a circadian clock. Karen explains.
Karen: And so if you imagine that you wanted to fly south, if you knew it was morning, you should keep the sun on your left side and move so that you keep the sun on your left side in the morning… and in the afternoon you want to keep the sun on your right side.
When it’s cloudy, they switch to a different compass that uses UV light to detect the angle of the earth’s geomagnetic poles.
But exactly how they manage to arrive at the same winter refuges as their ancestors YEAR AFTER YEAR – even though they’ve never been there before – has scientists scratching their heads.
Karen: we know how a monarch can figure out to go south… But we don’t understand their map – the fine details of how they get there are, are still a mystery. And I kind of love that about monarchs. I love that there are still a lot of really basic questions that we’re working on answering.
What scientists DO know, is that butterfly numbers at the overwintering sites in Mexico have been going down.
Annual counts at the winter sanctuaries began in the 90s. It’s a job led by the World Wildlife Fund and the Mexican government. But because actually counting millions of butterflies tightly clustered on trees is pretty much impossible, they instead measure how much space the winter colonies take up.
Karen: So if we look at those averages of the last decade and the decade from 20 to 30 years ago, we’ve had a decline of about 75%. It’s clearly a decline.
Last winter, monarchs occupied just under 3 hectares of forest. Scientists roughly estimate that in each hectare there are about 21 million butterflies, so that means around 60 million monarchs were there last winter.
30 years ago, they took up 18 hectares – six times as much space. Here’s Greg, the Canadian research scientist.
Greg: And just to put this in perspective, if you think about the inside perimeter of an Olympic sized track and field track, that’s about one hectare. And our conservation goal across the three countries here is six hectares – we think we need the population to be up around six hectares so that we’re minimizing the chance of that population ever going extinct. And we’re kind of sitting around between 2 and 3 right now.
Another type of migrating monarch that lives west of the Rocky Mountains has seen even steeper declines. This western population that spends the winter on California’s coast has shrunk by around 95% since the 80s.
More research is needed, but there are a bunch of reasons believed to be behind the declining overwintering populations.
Karen: In some ways it’s sort of like a death by a thousand cuts analogy. So there are a lot of threats.
But Karen says a big one is the loss of habitat – both where the butterflies breed in summer and along their migration route. An important factor here is the widespread use of the herbicide glyphosate in corn and soy fields in the US Midwest from the late 90s.
Karen: So there isn’t milkweed in these corn and soybean fields anymore.
Milkweed is a flowering plant that’s crucial for this species. It’s the only plant they lay their eggs on… and it’s the only thing monarch caterpillars eat.
Karen: And that means that what was probably the most important source of habitat for the monarchs disappeared… It’s just left on these little patches. So they have to travel a lot farther in order to find habitat to lay their eggs on.
She says insecticides used in agriculture can also be fatal for monarchs. And the butterflies can get infected by parasites that shorten their lifespan and hamper their ability to migrate.
It’s a grueling journey. On the way to Mexico, they could also starve to death if they can’t find nectar, or be taken out by storms, hunted by birds, or hit by cars.
Greg: If the weather conditions are such that they’re flying low to the ground, then there’s a high probability that they might get struck by a vehicle. Just the average monarch butterfly in North America has to cross 3,000 roads on its migration down towards Mexico. So that’s a threat.
That’s something Greg says they’ve been able to see with the new trackers…
Greg: there’s been a couple of occasions where there’s a monarch where the signal all of a sudden stops and is beside a road. And so presumably that monarch might have been struck by a car and the transmitter’s just lying on the side of the road. And it keeps pulsing. And if you zoom in on the map, you can say, okay, this is right beside a freeway, for example.
Climate change is also threatening to disrupt the butterflies’ life cycle. Rising temperatures and drought can affect how much milkweed there is… and take a toll on the nectar plants the butterflies feed on to fuel their migration.
Extreme storms that bring freezing temperatures to their winter homes can be devastating. A rain and snow storm in 2016, for example, wiped out around a third of the butterflies in the Mexican colonies. And these storms are becoming more common.
Researchers in Mexico have also predicted that the high-altitude fir forests monarchs shelter in could disappear by 2090 because of climate change.
Karen: we don’t really know what will happen to monarchs if we lose the forest ecosystem that they’re using now.
There’s a lot of uncertainty. But Karen says she’s worried not enough is being done to try to turn things around.
Karen: So that’s kind of depressing to in my lifetime to have seen their numbers decline so much… then I can get pretty hopeful when I think about all of the scientists… I see how engaged people are and trying to understand them and figure out what we can do, and then doing things to help them… What makes me feel kind of depressed and unhopeful about the situation is how, as a society, we aren’t really using this knowledge well. So we understand more and more about the impacts of climate change, but we aren’t doing everything we can to mitigate climate change.
Since first deploying the new tags, Greg and other researchers have been busy. They’ve got a lot of data to sift through.
Greg: So just to give you an idea, we put out 430 tags as a collaborative across the US and Canada last year, and we had over 400,000 detections of these butterflies.
In the tracks of all these insects, they want to find out things like which locations are popular butterfly rest stops. Or how survival rates change from region to region.
Greg says the idea is then to use these insights to decide where to expand and protect butterfly habitat.
Greg: We’re able to see where there’s a lot of overlap in their migration and where they start funneling through the same geographical area. And if we were three governments working together, the Canadian, Mexican and US governments, and we were wanting to invest our conservation dollars to make sure they have enough habitat during their migration, then these areas of overlap or areas of concentration or funnel points would be where we would do our investment. So we didn’t have that level of detail before, and now we’re finally able to get it.
Another thing the data is making clear: not all eastern monarchs head to Mexico to spend the winter. Thanks to the trackers, Greg says the researchers might be able to identify winter refuges – not on their radar – that may also need to be protected.
In the long-term, Greg hopes to be able to see how monarch routes and survival rates change over time – and find out how that’s affected by things like drought, habitat quality, and storms.
Greg: Are there periods where they’re really slowed down and they stall out during their migration? Are there periods where we’re losing a lot of signals from tags and is that associated with weather? And what that’s going to allow us to do is forecast into the future where we might see trouble or in terms of are these kind of weather events that are prohibiting them from completing their migration, are they increasing in frequency? And then we can hindcast and see, has it always been this way? Or are things getting worse? And that type of question, we just don’t know.
Being able to follow the butterflies up close year after year means authorities can also monitor how well any new habitat restoration projects are working.
Greg says there’s some evidence, for example, that campaigns to plant milkweed and nectar-rich plants in city gardens and people’s yards might be paying off. Because the trackers have shown that migrating monarchs seem to be hanging out in these places.
Greg: We had a monarch that crossed the Great Lakes from Long Point, Ontario, Canada … landed in Ohio, and went through Cleveland, and it went right through the middle of the city like it didn’t try to go around the city. And so what that tells me is that if I’m encouraging people to plant nectar flowers in their gardens or on their balconies to help monarchs and other pollinators, then we have some pretty concrete proof now to show that monarchs are definitely moving through your backyard and moving through your city.
Greg released 90 tagged monarchs this year – triple what he released last time. And of course, he’s keeping an eye on them every day. Not all of them will make it, but he’s confident policy makers/scientists have the tools to make sure the species will.
Greg: This is one where we can actually make a difference. We know what the drivers are that are causing their population declines. And so I think we can we can right the ship.
As for Karen, she’s planning to go back to the overwintering grounds in Mexico twice this winter. Something she’s really looking forward to – even if the spectacle isn’t as big as it was when she first visited in the 90s.
Karen: Monarchs have just been such a part of my life because I study them all summer up here. So I feel kind of a connection to them when I see them in Mexico.
When she sees the butterflies gathering in their millions, she likes to imagine the different stories they have, and what they’ve been through to get there.
Karen: Might have come from my yard, might have come from a milkweed growing on a crack in a sidewalk, might have come from a beautiful, pristine prairie. It’s just kind of amazing to think of that. And also to think of the survival… there’s just a lot of things that make it really difficult for a butterfly or a caterpillar ever to get to be an adult. So, we’re just looking at the amazing ones that survived, you know, being eggs and caterpillars and pupae. And then they got to be adults and they survived that migration. So, you know, we’re looking at the really amazing monarchs that made it.
That’s it for today. And if you’d like to track the tagged monarch butterflies reaching Mexico this year, or flying back to the US next spring, you can download the free Project Monarch Science app and take a look.
Special thanks to Court Whelan who provided the audio of monarch butterflies at the start of the episode.














